If you grew up in the 90s, there’s a good chance that Don’t Tell Mom The Babysitter’s Dead was a staple in your movie rotation. Released in 1991, this teen comedy has all the ingredients that made it an instant cult classic: a quirky premise, unforgettable characters, and a star-studded cast. The story follows Sue Ellen, a teenager who unexpectedly becomes the head of her household when her babysitter dies while her parents are away. Chaos and hilarity ensue as Sue Ellen steps up to manage her siblings and hold down a job, all while navigating the challenges of growing up.
Over the years, the movie’s mix of teen rebellion, family dynamics, and a good dose of 90s humor has kept it relevant. But it’s the talented cast that made the movie so memorable. Let’s take a closer look at the actors who brought these unforgettable characters to life.
The Stars of Don’t Tell Mom The Babysitter’s Dead
| Actor | Character | Notable Roles |
|---|---|---|
| Christina Applegate | Sue Ellen Crandell | Christina Applegate steals the show as Sue Ellen, a teenager who finds herself in charge of her entire household after her babysitter dies. While Applegate is probably best known for her iconic role as Kelly Bundy in Married… with Children, she’s also had a standout career in films like Anchorman and Dead to Me. |
| Joanna Cassidy | Mrs. Sturak (the Babysitter) | Joanna Cassidy plays the ill-fated babysitter, Mrs. Sturak, whose sudden death sets the story in motion. A seasoned actress, Cassidy’s credits include Blade Runner, Six Feet Under, and The Mindy Project. |
| Keith Coogan | Bryan Crandell | Keith Coogan, as Bryan, Sue Ellen’s mischievous younger brother, brings an infectious energy to the film. Coogan also starred in Adventures in Babysitting and Toy Soldiers. |
| Daniel Harris | Zachary Crandell | Daniel Harris, who plays the youngest Crandell sibling, Zachary, brings the right mix of sweetness and sass. Harris is a horror legend, best known for his roles in Halloween 4 and Halloween 5. |
| David Lipper | Kenneth Crandell | David Lipper plays Kenneth, the teenage brother who’s a bit of a troublemaker. Lipper also had a memorable role in the TV series Hang Time and appeared in Full House. |
| Christopher Pettiet | Walter Crandell | Christopher Pettiet plays Walter, the youngest of the Crandell kids. His sweet, innocent portrayal adds a touch of tenderness to the film. Pettiet was also in The Wonder Years and The Outsiders. |
| Soleil Moon Frye | Dawn (Sue Ellen’s Friend) | Soleil Moon Frye, known for her role as Punky Brewster in the 80s, plays Dawn, Sue Ellen’s supportive friend. Frye brought her trademark quirky charm to the role. |
| Claudia Christian | Roberta (Sue Ellen’s Friend) | Claudia Christian plays Roberta, another of Sue Ellen’s friends who lends emotional support when the family’s world is turned upside down. Christian is best known for her role in Babylon 5. |
The Supporting Cast: Adding Extra Flavor
The supporting cast of Don’t Tell Mom The Babysitter’s Dead may not have been in the spotlight as much, but their contributions were just as important in shaping the movie’s comedic and heartfelt moments. Here are some of the key supporting players:
| Actor | Character | Notable Roles |
|---|---|---|
| Eda Reiss Merin | Mr. Crandell | Eda Reiss Merin plays Mr. Crandell, the absentee father of the Crandell kids. Though he’s hardly around, his presence looms over the family dynamics. Merin’s credits include The Muppets Take Manhattan and As Time Goes By. |
| John Getz | Garry (Sue Ellen’s Love Interest) | John Getz plays Garry, Sue Ellen’s handsome (and somewhat aloof) boss who eventually becomes her love interest. You might recognize Getz from The Social Network and Blood Simple. |
| Kimmy Robertson | Patty (Sue Ellen’s Co-worker) | Kimmy Robertson plays Patty, a quirky co-worker who helps Sue Ellen navigate the adult world of office politics. Robertson also starred in Twin Peaks, where she portrayed Lucy Moran. |
| Jessica Tuck | Miss O’Malley | Jessica Tuck plays Miss O’Malley, a strict but well-meaning supervisor at Sue Ellen’s job. Tuck has appeared in One Life to Live and True Blood, bringing her unique blend of tough and tender to the role. |
| Jack McGee | Dean (Sue Ellen’s Boss) | Jack McGee plays Dean, Sue Ellen’s boss, who is tough but eventually sees her for the capable young woman she is. McGee is known for The Fighter and Rescue Me, and he brings a no-nonsense attitude to the role. |
Why the Cast Still Matters Today
While the movie’s premise and hilarious moments certainly helped it become a 90s staple, it’s the cast that made Don’t Tell Mom The Babysitter’s Dead truly unforgettable. Christina Applegate’s performance as Sue Ellen remains one of her career-defining roles, and it set the stage for her successful transition into both comedy and drama.
The rest of the cast, from the mischievous Bryan (Keith Coogan) to the rebellious teen-turned-leader Sue Ellen, added layers of depth to what could have otherwise been a simple slapstick comedy. The film balanced its lighthearted moments with genuine emotion, especially when it came to the relationships between the Crandell siblings.
Even today, fans rewatch the film, quoting their favorite lines and reminiscing about the era. The cast’s chemistry and the film’s relatable themes—growing up, taking on responsibility, and dealing with family drama—continue to resonate.
Conclusion: A 90s Classic That Still Holds Up
The cast of Don’t Tell Mom The Babysitter’s Dead played an essential role in making this film a cherished classic. With standout performances from Christina Applegate, Keith Coogan, and a host of talented actors, the movie continues to be a beloved throwback for fans of all ages. Whether you’re revisiting it for the 20th time or discovering it for the first time, the performances of the cast are a big reason why this movie still holds a special place in our hearts.
If you haven’t seen it yet, grab some popcorn and settle in for a fun ride back to the 90s—you won’t regret it!
